Obligation, Advice and Prohibition
We use the following expressions to talk about obligation, advice, lack of obligation and prohibition.
| have to / must + base verb | Obligation |
| should + base verb | Positive advice |
| don't have to + base verb | No obligation |
| shouldn't + base verb | Negative advice |
| mustn't / can't + base verb | Prohibition |
1. Obligation
We use have to / must + the base form of a verb to say that it is very important or necessary to do something, for example, when talking about rules or responsibilities.
I have to start work at eight o'clock every day.
You must wear a seat belt when driving a car.
Have to
"Have to" is a main verb, so we use "do" or "does" to make negative sentences and questions.
+She has to go.
-She does not / doesn't have to go.
+?Does she have to go?
-?Doesn't she have to go?
We use "have to" with I / you / we / they and "has to" with he / she / it.
We don't normally contract "have" or "has" directly with the subject when using "have to". For example, "I've to go" is not normally used in standard English.
Must
"Must" is the same for all persons (e.g. I / you / he / she / it / they + must + do ...).
He must finish the project before Friday.
"Have to" is generally more common in everyday conversation. "Must" is often used in official rules, notices and signs.
Visitors must show their ID cards at the entrance.
Questions with "have to" are more common in everyday English than questions with "must".
2. Advice
We use should + the base form of a verb to give advice or say what we think is the right thing to do.
You look very tired. You should rest a little.
You shouldn't spend so much money on clothes.
We often use "I think" or "I don't think" before a clause with "should".
I think you should change your lifestyle.
I don't think you should eat so much fast food.
"Should" is an auxiliary verb and is the same for all persons (e.g. I / you / he / she / it / they + should + do ...). We simply put "not" after "should" to make negative sentences and put "should" before the subject to make questions.
+She should call her dad.
-She should not / shouldn't call her dad.
+?Should she call her dad?
-?Shouldn't she call her dad?
We can use "must", "mustn't" or "have to" instead of "should" when we want to give stronger advice.
You shouldn't / mustn’t smoke. It’s bad for your health.
3. No Obligation
We use don't have to + the base form of a verb to say that something is not necessary or obligatory. In these situations, doing something is optional. We can do it if we want, but we don't need to.
You don't have to cook a carrot before eating it.
My daughter doesn't have to get up early on Sundays.
Remember that "don't have to" doesn't mean something is forbidden. It simply means that it isn't necessary.
4. Prohibition
We use mustn't / can't + the base form of a verb to say that something is prohibited or forbidden. We often use these expressions to talk about rules.
You mustn't / can't smoke on an airplane.
Students mustn't / can't use their phones during the exam.
"Can't" can also express inability, depending on the context.
He can't swim. (inability)
You can't park your car in front of the hospital entrance. (prohibition)
"Mustn't" and "don't have to" have completely different meanings. "Mustn't" means something is forbidden or not allowed. "Don't have to" means something is not necessary, but you can do it if you want.
We mustn't wear jeans to work. (It's forbidden to wear jeans at work. It's a rule.)
We don't have to wear jeans to work. (It's not necessary, but we can wear them if we want.)
We often use "have to", "don't have to", "must" and "can't" with impersonal "you" to talk about people in general.
You have to show your ticket before getting on the train. (All passengers need to show their tickets.)
You must follow the instructions on the medicine bottle. (Everybody needs to do that.)
You can't feed the animals at the zoo. (Nobody is allowed to do this.)
Exercises
Circle the correct form printed in italics.
1.You must / should wear a seat belt when driving a car. It's the law.
You must wear a seat belt when driving a car. It's the law.
2.I'm really tired. I think I should / don't have to go to bed earlier.
I'm really tired. I think I should go to bed earlier.
3.You don't have to / mustn't bring any food. We've already prepared everything.
You don't have to bring any food. We've already prepared everything.
4.Students can't / don't have to talk during the exam. It's against the rules.
Students can't talk during the exam. It's against the rules.
5.She doesn't have to / can't work on Saturdays. Her office is closed.
She doesn't have to work on Saturdays. Her office is closed.
6.You must / don't have to show your passport at the airport before boarding your flight.
You must show your passport at the airport before boarding your flight.
7.You can't / shouldn't take photographs in this museum. It's forbidden.
You can't take photographs in this museum. It's forbidden.
8.He shouldn't / doesn't have to eat so much fast food. It's not good for his health.
He shouldn't eat so much fast food. It's not good for his health.